It’s time to change redistricting process

Editorials

Discussion

September 12, 2009

Anonymous Pharos-Tribune Sat Sep 12, 2009, 05:33 PM EDT

Indiana Secretary of State Todd Rokita is right. It’s time to shake up the way this state draws its congressional and legislative districts.

Rokita pitched a plan last week that would make it illegal for lawmakers to consider political data when coming up with district boundaries.

Some have suggested that lawmakers should be taken out of the process, but legislative leaders say it’s too late for that this time around. They say the only way to take redistricting out of the hands of lawmakrs would be to amend the constitution and the process to do that would take at least until 2012. The legislature faces a deadline of 2011 to come up with new maps reflecting next year’s census.

The fact is, though, that lawmakers can improve the process without taking themselves out of the picture.

As it now stands, many districts are drawn to be safe seats. The old joke is that one party so outnumbers the other in such districts that even a yellow dog could win out over a qualified candidate from the minority party.

That’s not the way our elected representatives should be chosen. Competitive elections would result in the election of representatives who would be more responsive to the concerns of individual voters and less obligated to the vested interests in Indianapolis and Washington.

During a speech unveiling his plan, Rokita showed a film clip of Indiana residents viewing the shapes of legislative districts and guessing what they looked like. The responses included a dog, dragons, alligators and a squirrel.

He noted that since the current district maps were drawn in 2001 candidates in two of every five legislative races have run without major party opposition.

Rokita believes districts should follow existing county, city and township lines as closely as possible. He also favors having each of the state’s 50 Senate districts include two of the 100 House districts.

Such a plan simply makes sense. The problem is that the only way it will pass is to win legislative support, and the early returns there aren’t all that promising. Legislative leaders from Rokita’s own party have already come out saying that Rokita has overstepped his bounds by inserting himself into a debate that should be the province of the legislature.

Frankly, that’s just wrong. The people who own these maps are the taxpayers, and the interests the mapmakers should be looking out for are those of voters.

Rokita appears to be doing that. We hope both lawmakers and voters will take notice.

On the Web

www.rethinkingredistricting.com

The issue

Indiana lawmakers every 10 years redraw congressional and legislative districts to reflect population shifts recorded in the latest census.

Our view

There is no reason for politics to enter into the process.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Editorials

White should not return to office
The conviction of Indiana’s secretary of state on charges of voter fraud has left Republicans and Democrats fighting over who will hold the office. No matter how the fight comes out, Charlie White’s ouster from office should be permanent.

February 7, 2012
A grand success for Indianapolis
The just-ended Super Bowl was the result of decades of preparation. Indianapolis left a great impression on the thousands of visitors who descended on the city.

February 6, 2012
Should schools teach creationism?
The Indiana General Assembly is considering a measure that would allow public schools to teach creationism as long as they include instruction on other reliigious theories. Broadening the instruction to include other religions might address constitutional concerns, but the result might be a class the law’s supporters didn’t envision.

February 4, 2012
Giving every child a chance
Students from Columbia Middle School delivered a message of inclusion in a play last weekend. The message is one that can’t be repeated too often.

February 2, 2012
Testing lawmakers a good idea
A measure requiring drug testing for welfare recipients would also require drug testing for legislators. If lawmakers are going to impose such a requirement on welfare recipients, they should be willing to stand up to the same measure.

February 1, 2012
Peru delivers important message
The city of Peru collected $20,000 last year from property owners who failed to keep their yards mowed. An aggressive enforcement effort can help the city’s finances, but the benefits go beyond dollars and cents.

January 31, 2012
Jail GED program a great step
The issue
The Cass County Sheriff’s Department has begun offering GED
classes for its prisoners.

Our view
The department, and society at large, will see a huge return on that
investment.

January 30, 2012
Ambulance services aren’t cheap
Cass County commissioners are looking at alternatives to the ambulance service provided by Logansport Memorial Hospital. Commissioners will be fortunate to find a less expensive alternative.

January 29, 2012
‘Right to work’ moves to next chapter
The Indiana House passed a proposed “right to work” measure this week after Democrats finally ended their boycott. The fight now moves to the ballot box, and labor unions will be working hard in the coming months to elect friendlier candidates.

January 26, 2012
Healthy debate on farm safety
Agriculture interests are up in arms about proposed rules aimed at ensuring the safety of young farm workers. Public feedback on the proposed regulations will almost certainly make them more effective.

January 25, 2012
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

Discussion

It’s time to change redistricting process

The Indiana Senate last week approved a bill that would allow public schools to teach creationism in science classes as long as they included origin of life theories from other religions. Would you support such a measure?

Site Map

Contact Us