INDIANAPOLIS —
Almost two million new court cases were filed in Indiana last year, continuing an upward trend in litigation and prosecution that some state officials blame on “offense inflation.”
A report released Monday by the Indiana Supreme Court’s Division of State Court Administration shows a 16.5 percent increase in the number of criminal and civil cases filed in state courts since 2000.
The number of criminal cases have gone up by more than 17 percent in the decade while Indiana's population has increased by less than 6 percent since 2000.
Indiana Court of Appeals Chief Justice John Baker said the numbers reflect a more aggressive use of the courts.
“I don’t think we’ve misbehaved more in that time period,” Baker said.
But more bad behavior has become criminalized, he said, with punishments escalating. He said the number of criminal statues in Indiana’s penal code has gone from about 200 in 1977, when there was a major rewriting of Indiana’s laws, to nearly 2,000 today.
Baker also cited what he called “offense inflation” — violations that have escalated from infraction to misdemeanor and misdemeanor to felony. According to the report, one of the biggest increases is in class D felonies filed, from 39,114 to 51,524 in 2009, a nearly 32 percent increase.
The result of the rising numbers: Overcrowded court dockets and an increase in Indiana’s prison population. In 2009, for example, the prison population nationwide dropped 0.4 percent but in Indiana, it rose 5.3 percent. That’s the largest percentage increase in any state in the nation.
The report also indicates that in many counties, the number of judges and court personnel has not increased at the same pace as the rise in cases. In Boone County, for example, the judges there are carrying a heavier “weighted” case load (based on the time and resources it takes to process a case) than in any other county.
Last year, according to the report, it cost Indiana taxpayers almost $400 million to operate the courts. That amount could be reduced, Baker said, if judges would streamline and share their resources.
But he said too many judges rule over what they consider their “personal fiefdoms” for that to occur easily.
What the “2009 Indiana Judicial Service Report and Indiana Probation Report” also shows is just how many Hoosiers are impacted by the increase in criminal prosecutions.
Lilia Judson, executive director of the Division of State Court Administration, which issued the report, said 1 in 90 Indiana residents were charged with a felony in 2009. That’s up from 1 in 135 in 1990.
“Does that mean we’re more criminal than before? Or is law enforcement more active?” Judson said.
Not all counties saw a rise in court cases. Some, including Daviess, Rush, and Ripley counties in southern Indiana, saw the number of court cases either hold steady or decrease over the decade.
But what did rise in many counties, often at a higher rate than civil and criminal cases filed, were the number of cases in which the court had to step in to protect children from harm or neglect. The number of Child in Need of Services cases, known as CHINS, rose from 8,083 in 2000 to 12,625 in 2010, a 56 percent increase.
The 1,734-page, multi-volume report is posted online at www.in.gov/judiciary.
It includes a wide range of information about the courts, from the number of murder cases filed to the number of mortgage foreclosure filings.
The Indiana General Assembly requires the compilation of the annual report, now done electronically. The first one was compiled by hand in 1976.
• Maureen Hayden is statehouse bureau chief for CNHI’s Indiana newspapers. She can be reached at maureen.hayden@indianamediagroup.com.
Local News
Nearly 2 million new court cases filed in 2009
upreme Court officials say “offense inflation” may account for rise in Indiana court cases
- Local News
-
-
No jail for driver in fatal hit-and-run
A 25-year-old Logansport man admitted Thursday to leaving the scene of a deadly wreck last year, but he will not serve any time in jail as the result of a plea agreement.
-
Board backs 51 percent spike in utility rates
For Paul Hartman, the issue facing the Logansport Stormwater Management Board is pretty simple.
-
13-foot statue celebrating arts to stand in Logan
Logan’s Landing danced a little closer Thursday to sprucing up the downtown area and crafting the arts and design district it’s been longing to create.
-
Stormwater board OKs rate increase
The Logansport Stormwater Management Board this morning approved a 51 percent increase in its monthly rates.
-
LHS senior prank
As a senior prank, Logansport High School students moved the cow from in front of Happy Burger West to the Berry Bowl this morning. It was all in good fun, though. Bob Shanks, the owner of Happy Burger, was even on hand to pose for pictures.
-
‘It’s not about you’: Local mom shares journey of adopting foster children
Foster parenting isn’t always easy, says Juanita Jackson. Between caseworker visits and baby-sitting restrictions, the 42-year-old balances work and caring for five children as a single mom.
-
Longtime Lewis Cass teacher fired over license
Notwithstanding the impassioned pleas on Scott Rouch’s behalf, the Southeastern school board unanimously voted to cancel his teaching contract for “neglect of duty and other just causes.”
-
Jeremy Franklin charged with two felonies
A special prosecutor this week filed three charges, including two felony counts, against the son of the Logansport mayor.
-
Logan multiplex still in the works
Plans for a multiplex in Logansport are still in the works, but at least one city official hoped the process would move a bit quicker.
-
Ambulances moving: Hospital says change will save $200,000
Rural/Metro, Cass County’s newest ambulance service, told Logansport Memorial Hospital that it plans to move out of the ambulance garage at the end of its lease in September.
- More Local News Headlines
-
No jail for driver in fatal hit-and-run




