Canned hunting trips are a disgrace to the sport

Local Sports

Discussion

August 23, 2006

Anonymous Pharos-Tribune Wed Aug 23, 2006, 12:18 AM EDT

This is not an Indiana story but the parallels are striking.

Country music superstar Troy Gentry, half of the duo Montgomery Gentry, was federally charged with a violation of the Lacey Act on August 15, in Minnesota for shooting a tame black bear in 2004 within an enclosure, then falsely tagging the bruin as having come from the wild.

According to news reports, Gentry purchased the bear from Lee Marvin Greenly of Sandstone, Minnesota for $4,650. He was placed in a tree stand within a high-fence enclosure and waited about two hours before shooting the bear with his bow. A videotape of the “hunt” was then edited to make it appear as if it had occurred in the wild.

Does any of this sound familiar?

In case you’ve been under a rock, this is exactly the same scenario that landed professional bass fisherman Jimmy Houston and others in hot water during the 2002 investigation at Beller’s Place, a canned hunting outfit near Peru. Russell Beller plead guilty to three federal charges in 2005 and left the hunt business.

In this latest incident, Gentry’s attorney had a good explanation for all of accusations. He said the enclosure was “several acres” and the videotape was edited to cut “dead time.” Similar videos I have seen from Beller’s place did skillfully cut the dead time from the hunt and also artfully made sure that no sign of a fence was seen on the screen.

As an aside, wildlife photographers were saddened to learn that the bear, named Cubby, had met his demise. Many professional photographers from across the country had also paid to take pictures of the huge, famous bear on Greenly’s 80-acre Minnesota Wildlife Connection property. Reports note that this practice is somewhat controversial but very widespread in the outdoor media.

Greenly was also indicted on a number of charges unrelated to Gentry’s hunt, including guiding hunters into a nearby wildlife refuge where they illegally killed two bears.

As we have stated before, the more people learn about the methods and operation of canned hunts, the more unpopular they will become with the public. Apparently the federal government is also sitting up and taking notice.

One last note from someone with inside knowledge on a side topic brought up in this news item. At the risk of alienating many of my outdoor media pals, I feel it is my duty to keep reminding the public that much of what you see in outdoor media, especially television hunting shows, isn’t always a true and accurate representation of reality. The huge deer, bear, moose, elk, turkey, gophers, marmots, badgers, giraffes and other critters you see gracing the covers of magazines are often shot from an angle where you can’t see the fence behind them. Unfortunately, that is the reality.

I could name names, but halos have a way of become a noose for holier-than-thou writers.

Another bad idea

The World Hunting Association (WHA) is sponsoring a series of nonfatal deer hunting tournaments in Michigan where hunters will tranquilize deer for cash prizes.

While the people associated with this event are enthusiastic and believe it will attract positive interest in hunting, I believe it will do just the opposite. Other pro-hunting organizations have also come out against the tournament on general principals and the idea that deer shouldn’t be treated like woodland largemouth bass. There is also the sleazy-money angle of the affair to tarnish the image of participating hunters.

This is such a bad idea for so many reasons we don’t have enough newsprint to begin a list.

Brent Wheat is a longtime Hoosier outdoors columnist. He can be reached through the sports department at (574) 722-5000 Ext. 5180 or via e-mail at btwheat@wildindiana.com.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Local Sports

Berries cruise past Raiders, set up title game showdown
Hoosier Hysteria promises to be alive and well when the young and talented Berries (20-3) go up against the senior-laden two-time defending sectional champion McCutcheon Mavericks (19-3), ranked No. 8 in Class 4A, in tonight’s Logansport Sectional championship game. Tip-off is set for 7:30 p.m.

February 11, 2012
Comets topple Vikings to reach title game
With an increase in wins this season, the Lady Comets of Caston have taken another step in making this a very memorable season by defeating North White 38-30 during semifinal action Friday at the North White Sectional.

February 11, 2012
Slow start dooms Cass in loss at Wabash
After knocking off Class 2A No. 11 Oak Hill earlier in the week, Wabash’s girls basketball team proved once again white it is the defending sectional champion Friday night.

February 11, 2012
Winamac throttles North Newton in sectional play
Winamac’s girls basketball team defeated North Newton 61-35 Friday at a Class 2A North Judson Sectional.

February 11, 2012
Defending state runner-up Kokomo edges Logansport
For the second straight game Logansport’s boys basketball team went toe-to-toe against one of the state’s best teams for 32 minutes.

February 10, 2012 1 Photo
Hot-shooting Kings throttle Comets
Lewis Cass’ boys basketball team was on fire offensively in a 90-50 rout of Eastern in a Mid-Indiana Conference boys basketball game here Thursday night.

February 10, 2012
Comets bomb away on Squires in rout
After Caston’s boys basketball team lost consecutive games to Logansport and Carroll in early December, the Comets proceeded to rattle off 11 wins in a row.

February 10, 2012
Pullen had 2 runner-up finishes at Warsaw swim sectional
Lewis Cass senior Claire Pullen put together a solid four-year career in swimming.

It culminated with a runner-up finish in the 200-yard individual medley at the Warsaw Sectional last Saturday. She recorded a personal-best time of 2:24.6 en route to missing a spot in the state finals by just one place.

February 9, 2012 1 Photo
Lady Berries have new life
Logansport’s girls basketball team saw its tournament life flash before its proverbial eyes in Tuesday’s Class 4A Logansport Sectional opener against Kokomo.

February 9, 2012
Logansport boys in midst of tough stretch
Right now Logansport’s boys basketball team is going through the teeth of its schedule.

Six nights after facing a top-ranked Muncie Central squad in Indianapolis, the Berries (9-6, 1-3 North Central Conference) travel to Kokomo tonight to take on the Class 4A, No. 6-ranked Wildkats (16-3, 4-1).

February 9, 2012
More Local Sports Headlines

Local Sports

Search Results

Discussion

Canned hunting trips are a disgrace to the sport

The Indiana Senate last week approved a bill that would allow public schools to teach creationism in science classes as long as they included origin of life theories from other religions. Would you support such a measure?

Site Map

Contact Us