Bayh right in the middle of debate

Opinion

Related Photos

Discussion

October 31, 2009

by Kelly Hawes Pharos-Tribune Sat Oct 31, 2009, 11:33 PM EDT

Indiana’s junior senator seems to have found himself in the middle of the national health care debate.

Conservatives are pointing to Evan Bayh as an example other Democrats might do well to emulate. They see his opposition to a public option as a responsible position. He’s standing up to his big-spending colleagues in the Democratic Party.

Liberals, on the other hand, see Bayh as abandoning his base, and they’ve made the threat that he could lose support for his re-election campaign next year if he ends up siding with the Republicans on this fight.

The numbers might be on their side.

The Progressive Change Campaign Committee and a group called Democracy for America last week released results of a survey finding that Indiana voters favor a public option by a margin of 52 percent to 42 percent. The survey found independents favoring it by an even larger margin, 59 percent to 33 percent.

In the same survey, 35 percent of independents responded that they would be less likely to vote for Bayh next fall if he joined Republicans in filibustering a public option. That compares to 13 percent who said they would be more likely to support him.

Among Democrats, the survey put the margin at 51 percent to 7 percent.

At the same time, 54 percent of Democrats said support of a filibuster would make them less likely to support Bayh in the primary, compared to 6 percent who said they would be more likely.

Of course, what people say in a survey and what they do in the voting booth might be two different things.

It seems unlikely that Bayh will face a serious challenge in the primary, and it seems even less likely that those in favor of health care reform will be voting Republican next year.

Bayh’s appeal has always been to moderate voters, and his position on health care would seem to line up with that approach.

He has promised to support moving forward with a debate on the Senate floor, and he has said he will work hard to craft what he calls “affordable legislation that reduces the deficit and lowers health care costs for Indiana families and small businesses.”

One thing Bayh might want to keep in mind is another result of that same survey: Hoosiers aren’t huge fans of insurance companies.

Seventy-seven percent of those responding to the survey said they believed insurance companies put profit above the health of patients. That’s compared to 11 percent who said they believed companies put patients’ health first.

And here’s another point worth noting: Fifty-two percent of those responding said they thought Bayh’s $1.5 million in campaign contributions from health and insurance interests hurt his judgment on health care. That compares to 29 percent who said they didn’t believe those contributions hurt his judgment on the issue.

For Bayh, the trick in this debate will be to nail down a compromise without seeming to move too far left or too far right of center.

If you can trust the numbers, the majority of Bayh’s constituents do want some form of health care reform.

They want a system that will focus on the health of Hoosiers and not on the bottom lines of insurance companies. They would seem to favor some form of public option.

And if they don’t get what they want, a lot of voters say they might take it out on Bayh at the polls next year.

As it now stands, Bayh can pretty much count on a motivated conservative base. He isn’t likely to get many of those votes regardless of how this debate comes out.

The fight, as it always is, will be over the moderates. Bayh needs to keep the moderates happy while making sure he doesn’t make the liberals so mad they stay home.

• Kelly Hawes is managing editor of the Pharos-Tribune. He can be reached at 574-732-5155 or kelly.hawes@pharostribune.com.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Opinion

An outstanding community effort
United Way of Cass County announced this week that it had raised more than $600,000 in its most recent campaign. The campaign’s success is a testament to the generosity of local residents and to the great work of the United Way and its member agencies.

February 9, 2012
Thorns & Roses
Thorns & Roses is our staff’s compilation of the best and worst of the week, but if you have your own nominations, feel free to send them along for publication in our Public Forum. Submissions of up to 400 words may be addressed to Pharos-Tribune, 517 E.
Broadway, Logansport IN 46947. The fax number is 574-732-5070, and the email address is publicforum@pharostribune.com. Don’t forget to include your name, address and daytime telephone number.

February 9, 2012
Public forum
Letters of up to 400 words may be submitted to Public Forum, Pharos-Tribune, 517 E. Broadway, Logansport IN 46947. The email address is publicforum@pharostribune.com, and the fax number is 574-732-5070.

February 8, 2012
Another step forward for local trails
Local officials broke ground this week on the planned Eel River Run from downtown to Riverside Park. The project will expand a trail system of which the community can be proud.

February 8, 2012
White should not return to office
The conviction of Indiana’s secretary of state on charges of voter fraud has left Republicans and Democrats fighting over who will hold the office. No matter how the fight comes out, Charlie White’s ouster from office should be permanent.

February 7, 2012
Even in names, Eli beats Peyton
Columnist Dave Kitchell looks at the names of Cass County's babies in 2011 - and the effect they may have had on the Super Bowl.

February 7, 2012
Public forum
Letters of up to 400 words may be submitted to Public Forum, Pharos-Tribune, 517 E. Broadway, Logansport IN 46947. The email address is publicforum@pharostribune.com, and the fax number is 574-732-5070.

February 7, 2012
A grand success for Indianapolis
The just-ended Super Bowl was the result of decades of preparation. Indianapolis left a great impression on the thousands of visitors who descended on the city.

February 6, 2012
Public forum
Letters of up to 400 words may be submitted to Public Forum, Pharos-Tribune, 517 E. Broadway, Logansport IN 46947. The email address is publicforum@pharostribune.com, and the fax number is (574) 732-5070.

February 6, 2012
Public forum
Letters of up to 400 words may be submitted to Public Forum, Pharos-Tribune, 517 E. Broadway, Logansport IN 46947. The email address is publicforum@pharostribune.com, and the fax number is (574) 732-5070.

February 4, 2012
More Opinion Headlines

Opinion

Search Results

Related Photos

Discussion

Bayh right in the middle of debate

The Indiana Senate last week approved a bill that would allow public schools to teach creationism in science classes as long as they included origin of life theories from other religions. Would you support such a measure?

Site Map

Contact Us