PUBLIC FORUM: Columnist wrong about vouchers

Opinion

Discussion

November 29, 2012

PUBLIC FORUM: Columnist wrong about vouchers

Anonymous Pharos-Tribune Thu Nov 29, 2012, 05:59 AM EST

— I was disappointed to read Mr. Southern’s latest column talking about Indiana’s voucher program (Pharos-Tribune, Nov. 26), which was filled with very inaccurate information. To begin with, I am confused by the assertion that primarily upper income families are using vouchers. The first requirement to be eligible is that a family’s income must fall below 150 percent of the poverty line. In fact, 81 percent of families in Indiana receiving vouchers fall below the federal poverty line, making the implication that the “upper half” are the ones benefiting from this program profoundly incorrect.

Mr. Southern proclaims that Hamilton County was particularly excited about the voucher program. Since they fall within our Diocese, I know each of the five leaders of the largest non-public schools in Hamilton County very well. While these schools represent the largest percentage of total students in our Diocese by county, they make up the smallest percentage of voucher students. Where are the largest concentrations of voucher students found in Indiana? Sixty-six percent come from urban schools with Indianapolis and Gary seeing the largest number of participating students. Forty-eight percent of participating students come from minority households.

Quite simply, Indiana’s voucher program is designed to benefit lower income families by giving them the same educational choices as families with means.

The assertion that state-funded vouchers violate the separation of church and state is an unfortunate argument that has been defeated in every state with a voucher program, as well as in the U.S. Supreme Court. It is no different than when grants go to pay a student’s tuition at a religious-affiliated college, or when Medicare or Medicaid payments are made to religious hospitals. The voucher program does not establish a government-sponsored church; it merely gives families the opportunity to choose the school environment that is the best fit for their family.

In conclusion, it is a mystery to me why some believe that a successful voucher program can only come at the expense of public education. In Cass County, All Saints Catholic School enjoys an excellent working relationship with the area public school corporations. When our school is effective, it benefits each of the county school districts our kids feed into.

I would urge Mr. Southern to more carefully research his information and consider that a quality education system in Indiana includes both successful public and successful non-public schools.

James McNeany, principal, All Saints Catholic School

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Opinion

THORNS & ROSES: Week of May 16
May 17, 2013
WOLFSIE: Writing on the walls
Sometimes when I am trying to think of an idea for my column, I just stare at the wall. That’s not a bad thing, because on the wall in my home office is a collection of special pieces of memorabi-lia that inspire me to write, reminding me of the talented people I have had the privilege to meet.

May 17, 2013
HAYDEN: From good to great in education not the way
On the campaign trail last year and early into his administration, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence said repeatedly that his goal as governor would be to take Indiana from “good to great.”

May 16, 2013
THEIR VIEW: Big Brother looms large in D.C.
The federal government, working under the cloak of secrecy, has been having a heyday at the expense of all Americans.
First we learn the IRS has been targeting conservatives — applications for tax-exempt status by tea party groups were wrongly singled out for extra scrutiny.

May 16, 2013
KITCHELL: Waste-to-energy a big waste of time
Had all of Logansport attended the Indiana Society of Professional Journalists Awards ceremony last month in Indianapolis, we all would have learned that the No. 1 editorial written in the state in the past year was about a subject that sounds familiar to Logansport residents.

May 15, 2013
THEIR VIEW: Keep teens safe on the roadways
Indiana was able to achieve welcome decreases in teen-driving deaths after adopting graduated driver’s license laws. But it appears some of the benefits of easing teen drivers more slowly into the responsibilities associated with driving are leveling off.

May 15, 2013
MARCUS: Where to put your money
Snail Smith’s real name is Stanley, but his contorted windup and slow pitches gave him the nickname, Snail, during his short baseball career.

May 14, 2013
THEIR VIEW: Indiana loses a respected leader
At a time when our nation was deeply divided by war, social upheaval and political corruption, Otis R. “Doc” Bowen brought stability to Indiana in his eight years as governor largely through the strength of his personal integrity. He was respected, revered even, not only by fellow Republicans but also by independents and Democrats for his deep commitment to the state and its people.

May 14, 2013
OUR VIEW: Mothers the greatest gift of all
Our mothers help guide us through the world around us, helping us sidestep disaster if at all possible. She holds our hand as we become the person we were meant to be. She knew us from the beginning, and if she had it her way, she’d know us to the very end.

May 12, 2013
PUBLIC FORUM: Mayor tells residents of positive change
When the residents of Logansport elected me as their new mayor in November 2011, it was truly an honor.
Our city was battling back from a devastating loss of 1,500 jobs in five years, a recession that wasn’t letting up on the household income of our residents, a divided fire protection commitment in our county and an overall sense of loss in our community.

May 12, 2013
More Opinion Headlines

Opinion

Search Results

Discussion

PUBLIC FORUM: Columnist wrong about vouchers

Do you think an Ohio prosecutor should seek the death penalty against the man accused of imprisoning three women at his home for about a decade and forcing them to suffer miscarriages?

Site Map

Contact Us